This Christmas there are several games that found their way into our house, as I’m sure many have among the people who read this. Whether they were bought for you, a friend, a significant other, or a kid, Hillary Clinton wants, if she becomes president, to Protect The Children(TM) from unfavorable content. What is unfavorable? Well, the government will tell us, of course!
Now, she has long been for wanting the government to decide what is and is not suitible for kids. Two years ago she introduced the Family Entertainment Protection Act [FEPA]. It would have given retailers fines for selling Mature (M) or Adults Only (AO) rated games to under age kids. It didn’t pass.
(See here for an overview of all ratings, for those unfamiliar.)The AO rating is currently a kiss of death to a game. The prime example being when Manhunt 2 was initially given an AO rating not long ago. If a game receives an AO, the consoles won’t licence the game publisher so it can be released and played on their consoles. In other words, a game company can make a game as violent and sexually explicit as they like, but if they get an AO, Microsoft, Sony, et al won’t let it be playable on their equipment. And even if they could release it, many major retailers such as Circuit City and Best Buy won’t sell it.
In order to change it into an M rated game, Manhunt 2 was cut some, but even after getting the M rating, that wasn’t enough for Hillary and the usual bunch of anti-video game legislators. In November, US Senate members sent a letter to the ESRB, asking them to look at their rating system and that they felt Manhunt 2 deserved an AO rating. Despite never seeing or playing the game themselves.
The reasons she gives for wanting to Protect The Children(TM) are:
Research has shown that violent and sexually explicit media contribute to aggressive behavior, early sexual experimentation, obesity, and depression.
and
Studies have found that exposure to TV violence can increase the risk of aggressive behavior in children and may be related to attention problems later in life.
Those are some rather vague claims. But you know what? Even if those studies are correct, and there are even studies that claim there is no link, kids get exposure to violence from way more sources than video games. So why isn’t she wanting to curb violence shown on the news? Or in sports? I play a lot of violent games, but find boxing especially violent and pointless, for example.
Don’t get me wrong though. I am in favor of some kind of labeling for games and movies and such to help determine what is right for my baby grrl and for other parents. Although both seem to be missing the mark, and the movie rating system is very inconsistent. See This Film Is Not Yet Rated for excellent examples.
The funny thing is about the whole M versus AO rating, looking back at the Hot Coffee episode, was that Clinton, Lieberman and the bunch didn’t start their vocal outbursts until it was found out that gamers could mod the game to actually see *gasp* simulated sex acts. The killing and violence? Not happy about it, but OK! Pixels that kind of looked like they were having oral sex? Oh no! Protect The Children(TM)! We can’t have kids see any kind of sex! Just like the kid who was with his dad (uncle maybe…guessing dad though) watching Sin City, sitting in front of me at the theater. He was probably 10 or 12 maybe. The dad didn’t say a word during the violence. But as soon as the clothes started coming off and the sex happened, he covered the kid’s eyes with his hand and told him not to watch. When the same woman was lying dead, and many others getting their heads chopped off, he had no problem with him watching. Tell me that doesn’t send some kind of mixed up message to the kid. But while I may not approve of his parenting, I surely don’t believe it’s up to the government to tell him what he thinks is right for his kid to see.
Video games are just the latest in a long line of blames placed on an object for The Downfall Of Society(TM). Like rock n’ roll and comic books, they are but a form of entertainment and an outlet for people, both young and old, that doesn’t need government monitoring. Especially when it involves telling parents how to raise their kids.
Technorati tags: video games, ratings, think of the children, big brother