I found out about this story via an email from a coworker, who either read it on a blog or got it from someone who read the blog. It’s a conservative one for sure. He sent it to all of us, not knowing how liberal I am.
It came from an OpEd piece at Boston Herald about a guy whose 13 year old daughter was questioned by her pediatrician. Not about her health, but about her parent’s habits. Drinking, smoking, gun ownership, and if her daddy made her “feel uncomfortable”. All of those questions were asked without a parent present, or without their consent.
The conservative argument against this is two fold. They argue that the doctor is undermining the parent’s authority, while trying to split up the family. When it’s something the conservatives don’t like, it’s never ok to do this. (If mom and dad are atheists, then it would be ok for someone to teach the kid about Jesus. I have seen that said before.) The other one is related to the guns angle. You can imagine that the conservatives are up in arms over the invasion of privacy on their 2nd Amendment rights. (See that pun I did there? Ha.) Several of the comments to the story at the site have said that’s what we’ll get with Universal Health Care and if we elect “Hitlary” to the White House. The original post in the email my coworker sent me says:
I thought liberals got excited when the state sticks its nose into the bedroom. But if it turns out that Mom and Dad have their gun safe there, apparently liberals are okay with it.
The best one is this though, from the article’s comments:
i think we should give bush a 3rd term just to ensure a liberal morons doesn’t get into the white house
Wow. If only they would have spelled morons like “moran”, it would be an even better quote.
Despite my pacifism and pro-gun control, I do not want that type of questioning by the doctor to be routine. I do not want a gun personally, but I do want the option. Like a friend said the other day:
I want all the weapons and the most lethal ammunition I can stockpile. How the hell am I going to fight Nazi-types when they come to take me to the camps? […] Isn’t this why the Founding Fathers wanted the populace to have guns? So they could form militias to fight off enemies and stage revolutions if anti-democratic factions took over the govt.?
Yep, that’s what I think. (As The Clash’s song ‘The Guns of Brixton’ runs through my head. When they kick at your front door…How you gonna come?…With your hands on your head…Or on the trigger of your gun)
Overall though, that type of questioning was totally outside what the doctor should be doing as a routine. Now, if the child showed signs of some kind of abuse, neglect, or emotional problems, then the doctor has a duty to find out more information or to notify the proper authorities. But to just find out if a parent drinks, does drugs, or owns guns in order to Think of the Children (TM)? Would a typical Saturday game day in Oklahoma watching the Sooners, while drinking beer, be ok? Who decides what is right or wrong for the parents to be doing? That’s a Nanny State I do not want.
Huh…I just agreed with the right on an issue. Is it getting cold in hell?